Buried Truths

March is Women’s History Month, and while the history books are full of men on wooden ships, the real story of Nantucket was written by the women they left behind. For a century, Nantucket was a 'Nation of Women' who ran the banks, the shops, and the homes while their husbands were gone for three years at a time. But to find their true history, you have to look where the neighbors couldn't see: inside the chimneys and under the sand.
 

I grew up in Veracruz, where the sea and the port define your existence. If a ship goes down, everyone feels it. But the whalers who built Nantucket were on another level of maritime madness.

 

They would leave for three to five years. Think about that. You could leave before a child is born and come back just in time for their first day of school.

​

This meant that for a century, Nantucket wasn’t just an island; it was a physical and emotional "Nation of Women." The Quaker wives ran the banks, managed the shops, raised the kids, and kept the community functioning while the men were off chasing sperm whales in the South Pacific.

 

Which brings us to what they had to do to keep their sanity. Forget treasure chests of gold doubloons. If you want to find out what really happened here in 1840, you don’t look at the money — you look at the glass.

 

The Laudanum Carpet

If you take a stroll down Main Street, past the boutiques and art galleries, you are walking over a literal carpet of 19th-century drug bottles. This isn’t folklore; it’s infrastructure.

 

Back in the 1980s, when the town decided it needed modern sewer lines, they dug deep trenches through the historic district. The sandy soil, so good at preserving artifacts, hit what construction crews described as "veins" or "heaps" of small, turquoise-green and amber glass. These weren't milk bottles. They were opium dissolved in alcohol.

 

In the 18th century, a French visitor, St. John de Crèvecœur, famously noted that Nantucket women had adopted the "Asiatic custom" of taking a dose of opium every morning. Why? Because life was incredibly stressful. Laudanum was legal, cheap, and marketed as a cure for "nervous ailments" and the sheer agony of being a ‘widow’ with a living husband.

 

When the 'Marine Intelligence' column was essentially a casualty list, that morning dose wasn't just a habit, it was a survival strategy. When the bottle was empty, you just threw it into the backyard privy (the outhouse). The sand swallowed them whole. Today, they are everywhere. Ask a local landscaper; within the first three feet of digging, and you may strike a vein of 180-year-old "aspirin" glass.

​

The "He-at-Home" of Pine Street

But the real treasure isn't in the dirt. It’s in the walls. The Quakers were a private people, outward models of modesty and restraint. In the compact town of Nantucket, where everyone knew everyone's business, where do you hide something you can't display, but you can't bear to throw away?

​

You hide it in the core of the house: the central chimney.

 

In the late 1970s, local mason Barry Thurston was relining the flues of a historic home on Pine Street. Up on a "flue shelf", a small ledge inside the fireplace, he found a box that had been sealed up for nearly a century. Inside were personal effects belonging to Martha "Mattie" Coffin, the second wife of Captain James B. Coffin (a man who, naturally, spent his life at sea). The box contained letters from the 1890s, a man’s tobacco pipe, a clean shirt collar, and a five-inch plaster phallus, painted a wild-berry red at the tip.

 

The name "he-at-home" was a cheeky, literal description. it was the "husband" who stayed behind while the real one was off hunting sperm whales. In 18th and 19th-century Nantucket architecture, the massive central chimneys were often built with "pockets" or "dead spaces" between the flues. These weren't accidents; they were often used to store valuables or, as we now know, deeply private items that a woman in a strict Quaker society could never leave in a drawer. If the "He-at-home" was her secret, the chimney was her vault.

 

Seeing is Believing

The story was considered a myth, just a bit of salty wharf-talk, until writer Ben Shattuck tracked down the artifacts for an interview in The Common. He found them not in a museum, but still kept in a simple dress box by the family of the mason who uncovered them. It isn't a joke; it’s a time- capsule of human longing.​

 

It’s easy to look back on whaling history as a story of courageous men. But the real story of Nantucket, the one buried under the sand and hidden behind the flues, is the story of the women who waited. They needed faith, they needed patience, and they needed an 1840s version of a cocktail and a little plaster companion to make it through the three-year winter.

This Women’s History Month, when you see a mason repairing an 18th-century chimney or find a shard of turquoise glass in the sand, look past the legend of the whalers. Think of Mattie Coffin and the thousands like her who kept the fires burning. They survived the long, lonely winters with a dose of bottled courage and a hidden companion, proving that Nantucket’s most enduring spirits weren't the ones on ships, they were the ones kept tucked away.​