On a frigid winter night in 1980, Dr. Margaret Kilcoyne disappeared without a trace from Nantucket Island. This film carefully reconstructs the mystery through detailed research, interviews, and a disciplined adherence to the timeline as it unfolded. It revisits the unanswered questions that still linger more than four decades later — and explores why resolution never came.

​

Produced by Nantucket Community Television (NCTV), this is an exceptional piece of local documentary work — thoughtful, measured, and deeply rooted in the island’s history. It has not received the viewership it deserves.

​

Well worth your time.